Tyger vs Gator Tonneau Cover

Tyger vs Gator Tonneau Cover

No wonder Tonneau covers are essential to protect the truck bed cover and the cargo. What are the benefits of both? Which is better and why? These are some of the questions that we will answer in this article. There are many tonneau cover options today, but these two brands offer excellent quality at an affordable price. Read our comparison to see which product brings you more value for your money!

Gator vs Tyger Tonneau Table

Today, we have brought about two (Tyger Auto and Gator) most prominent brands in the truck accessories market. The overall debate will provide the readers with a detailed outline for choosing the best one.

Tyger Auto T5

Gator Etx 53204

69.93 x 28.12 x 4.5 inches

68 x 12 x 6 inches

Weight 76.7 pounds

Weight 24.2 pounds

Bed Size 5'8" 

Bed Size 5' 7"

Installation Time 5 minutes

Installation Time 20 to 30 minutes

Alloy aluminum frame and PC Polymer tarp

Industrial grade leather grain vinyl

Hard Trifold Tonneau Cover

Soft Roll-up Tonneau cover

Full Bed Access

Full Bed Access

Five years Warrenty

Lifetime on the frame, 10 years on the tarp

Suitable For 2014-2018 Chevy Silverado/GMC Sierra 1500

Suitable For 2009 - 2018, 2019/2020 Classic Ram 1500

Why Compare?

As stated earlier, both the brands are overwhelming and have a wide range of tonneau covers to meet every requirement. Buyers can choose from different ranges and types, and this can confuse the buyers to an extent. Moreover, the Tyger and GATOR conflict has flooded the internet. There are plenty of suggestions (most of them are not reliable).

Though these covers are both hyped, they differ in their features, performances, types, and materials. Thus, our team made an in-depth comparison between these tonneau covers to highlight and compare their features.

Material & Durability

Tyger tonneau cover excels in material and overall build quality; Thick PC polymer material is sandwiched by aircraft-grade alloy aluminum panels, ensuring ultimate strength to the cover. The alloy aluminum framing can hold up to 500lbs weight without any issue.

The hardware is built with stainless steel and a tough glass-filled nylon frame. Moreover, the PC polymer features plastic crossbows beneath and a smooth surface on the top. The overall structure is weathertight and prevents any outside adversity without any extra effort.

Heading towards the Gator one, it is built with the classic leather grain vinyl material. We all know how well vinyl performs regarding longevity and weight carrying. Despite being a soft tonneau cover, the industrial-grade vinyl material can carry delicate cargo under any circumstances. Additionally, vinyl can protect the truck bed from UV rays, rain, and snow. The tear-proof formula ensures utmost durability to the users.

Lock & Security

This Tyger tonneau cover features a high-end locking mechanism with commendable security, leaving the users tension-free. The quick-release clamps with stainless steel rods perform great against any potential theft. Also, there are safety buckles for extended security issues.

Apart from the human theft, this tonneau cover has an adjustable tension design. This tension design keeps the tarp tight in place to ensure weather protection. Gator also works excellent with latch locks; the heavy-duty latching is extremely sturdy and challenging for thieves to crack.

Just like the Tyger, the Gator tonneau cover also has a tension control design to ensure tight placement of the cover. This eventually results in climate protection from sun, rain, and snow.

Ease of Use

Tyger tonneau cover offers full bed access with additional functional flexibilities. This tonneau cover folds at three positions, making the operation process easy for the users. Moreover, the complex and sturdy material with a low-profile design ensures more cargo space.

But the most exciting fact of this tonneau cover is the enhanced gas mileage. As per different reviews, it can improve fuel economy by up to 10% through refining aerodynamics. Gator provides the same full truck bed access (just roll the cover towards the driver cab and secure by fastening the storage buckles) with the easy roll-up operation. The soft cover is very lightweight and highly convenient for storage.

Moreover, Gator is backed by its one-handed operation feature. A trigger latch on the driver’s side takes a single hand to operate. The cover mounts inside the bed rails and ensures complete access to the stake pocket holes. Users can use these holes with other accessories as well.

Installation Process

Tyger tonneau cover probably takes the least time to get installed. This pre-assembled tonneau cover can take hardly 5 minutes to install. It comes with quick-release clamps that ensure no drilling (no hassling) during installation. Users may need to cut small holes around the bed liner to secure the clamps properly during the installation.

Users need only clamp the rails and won’t require any drilling. The brand provides all the necessary equipment for cover assembly; thus, users need not buy any tools. The whole process takes a maximum of 20 to 30 minutes.

Price Range & Warranty

No wonder the Tyger tonneau cover is way more expensive with tons of high-end features. It retails for around 650$ on the official site. The price range may vary as per different E-commerce sites. Hard tri-fold models are usually on the higher side of the price. Though it is quite expensive, it may last for a long and is worth your money. The Tyger comes with a five-year warranty, and the brand suggests verifying the size carefully to prevent further hassles.

On the contrary, the Gator tonneau cover is around 200 to 250$ which is quite affordable compared to the Tyger cover. Gator has always been known for its magnificent products within the lowest budget, which amazes the customers with this particular cover. Gator offers a lifetime warranty for the frame and ten years warranty for the tarp.


The main difference between Gator and Tyger Tonneau is in the warranty period. Tyger offers Five years Warranty, Gator offers a Lifetime on the frame, and ten years on the tarp. To conclude the Tyger and GATOR feud.

I would like to point out the fact that both the covers are great considering the performance, material, and durability. Before investing in any of them, verify the bed size and your requirements (whether you need a soft roll-up cover or the hard tri-fold one). Both will serve the best, choose as per your convenience.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Yes, Gator is a good tonneau cover! They offer great protection for your truck bed and cargo, and they’re easy to install. Plus, their products are backed by a great warranty. So if you’re looking for a tonneau cover that will give you peace of mind, Gator is a great option.

Yes, Tyger tonneau covers can go through a carwash! In fact, they’re designed to withstand all kinds of weather and environmental conditions. So whether you’re dealing with rain, snow, or sun, your Tyger cover will keep your belongings safe and dry.

Yes, Gator covers do have a warranty! We want you to be completely satisfied with your purchase, so we offer a full warranty on all of our products. If you have any problems with your cover, simply contact us and we will work to make things right.

There is no definitive answer to the question of how tight a tonneau cover should be. However, there are a few general guidelines that can help you ensure that your cover is properly secured.


Tyger Cover

Gator Cover

Check Price on AmazonCheck Price on Amazon

Related Post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top